Tuesday, April 3, 2012

King v. Carmichael

           In Martin Luther King's book  Where Do We Go From Here he makes a strong point about the power of non-violence as a means of black Americans taking a stand and participating in their government. Martin Luther King considered non-violence to have a place in the progression of society, non-violent acts such as mass marches were a way for Black Americans to be a part of the change that needed to take place in their lives. Adversely, Stokely Carmichael felt that non-violence was a buzzword used to stop black people from defending themselves against  the prevalent violence used against them by the white man. Carmichael expresses that violence is a domineering factor in our society whether it is being used at home or in wars overseas. He says that non-violence seems to have no place in white america until they themselves are faced with violence. Although Carmichael brings up a good point in talking about the use of non-violence as a buzzword, I am more inclined to agree with Martin Luther King in his ideas that non-violence can be utilized to make change in our society. I do not disagree with Carmichael's thoughts on the amount of violence used against black Americans but I do feel he is wrong in his implications that the notion of non-violence can only exist as a means of  further oppressing African-Americans.

3 comments:

  1. i think you made some good points and overall it was ok but you could of added more detail and fixed up a few sentences. For example the fourth sentence you can word it differently and not go on so much without a period or comma. you shouldnt say i or you so much, use more general terms and you can still be specific and get your point across. Whats also good about this is that you have a significance and explained it well. it was easy to tell. i feel like you jump around a little stick to one detail and the rest should flow to the next. i dont like how you ended it with your opinion it should be but readers want to know which are facts! overall good job.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello Good103 my name is Pooja. I'm from Mr.Cooper's ENG101 class. I just read your blog and I got a sense of what the book is about. I like how you mentioned your view points in the last lines. It is always good to express a little what you feel about the topic. You can also use more keywords and evidence from the book using proper citations so that the blog is more interesting and more eye catching. Overall you did a great job.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi good103, I just read your blog and i was able to understand the different opinion about nonviolence between king and Carmicheal. You have fullfill the required asssessment and the structure of this blog makes me want to know more. You also state your opinion which is great. One thing that you should have include in this blog is an example about what did the white do to the black that they had to defend themself. Beside giving examplies your blog is outstanding and i whould like to know more about this topic.

    ReplyDelete